Skip to content

Original Frozen Custard

The Original Frozen
Custard in Lafayette, IN

Current Special:

Bacon Wrapped Hot Dogs!

Specialty Sundaes

Our TreatsLargeMediumSmall
Sundae Sizes
4 dips3 dips2 dips
Sundae
Vanilla Frozen Custard with your choice of topping: chocolate, strawberry, hot fudge, hot butterscotch, pineapple, boysenberry, tiger’s blood, marshmallow, lemon, cherry, or lime.
$5.99$4.59$3.59
Dirt Sundae
Vanilla Frozen Custard with crushed Oreo topping and a gummi worm.
$5.99$4.69$3.59
Banana Split
Vanilla Frozen Custard on sliced bananas with chocolate syrup, strawberries, pineapple, pecans and whipped cream.
$9.99$6.99
Turtle
Vanilla Frozen Custard with hot fudge, warm butterscotch, pecans and whipped cream.
$7.25$5.95$4.95
Fudge Muffin Sundae
Vanilla Frozen Custard on a double chocolate chip muffin topped with hot fudge and whipped cream.
$7.49
Black and Gold
Vanilla Frozen Custard with hot fudge, peanut butter, peanuts and whipped cream. Black and White: Vanilla Frozen Custard with hot fudge, marshmallow, peanuts and whipped cream.
$7.25$5.95$4.95
Pound Cake Sundae
Vanilla Frozen Custard on a Sara Lee Pound Cake with Strawberry topping—or—your choice of topping.
$7.49
Rocky Road
Chocolate Frozen Custard with marshmallow topping, peanuts and whipped cream.
$7.25$5.95$4.95
Mint Mountain
Vanilla Frozen Custard covered with chocolate sauce, Mint Chips and whipped cream.
$7.25$5.95$4.95
Soggy Bottom
Vanilla Frozen Custard on top of crushed OREO, covered with Peanut Butter and Marshmallow.
$7.25$5.95$4.95
Sundae With Nuts
Add Georgia Pecans—or—Spanish Peanuts.
$1.25
extra
Add whipped cream to a sundae, shake, or soda.$0.47
extra
Invent Your Own Sundae
STEP 1: Pick a SIZE - Small, Medium, or Large
STEP 2: Pick your Frozen Custard Flavor
STEP 3: Pick your Toppings!
---
Chocolate - Hot Fudge - Strawberry – Cherry - Pineapple – Butterscotch - Boysenberry - Lime - Marshmallow - Lemon – Vanilla -Peanut Butter - Tiger's Blood - M&M's – OREO – Peanut Butter & Jelly Bites - Reece’s Pieces – Snickers – Butterfinger - Sprinkles - Reece’s PB Cup --- Peanuts – Pecans - Sliced banana
---
STEP 4: Would you like real whipped cream on your sundae?
STEP 5: Name your Creation and ENJOY!
$5.99$4.59$3.59

Sandwiches

Our Sandwiches
Breaded Tenderloin$5.99
Grilled Tenderloin$5.99
Breaded Cod with Cheese$6.25
Breaded Chicken Breast$5.99
Chicken Salad Croissant$4.29
The Gavin$6.99
Grilled Chicken Burger$5.99
Condiments
Ketchup, mayo, onions, lettuce, dill pickles, sweet relish & mustard. Tomato, Nacho Cheese, Chili, Bacon available as an extra cost
Hot Dogs
Coney Cheese Dog$3.09
Cheese Dog$2.79
Coney Dog$2.79
Hot Dog$1.80
Flame Thrower Dog$3.09
Corn Dog$2.89
Condiments
Ketchup, mayo, onions, lettuce, dill pickles, sweet relish & mustard. Tomato, Nacho Cheese, Chili, Bacon available as an extra cost
Burgers
Double Cheese Burger$6.29
Double Hamburger$5.29
Cheese Burger
$4.49
Hamburger
$3.99
Condiments
Ketchup, mayo, onions, lettuce, dill pickles, sweet relish & mustard. Tomato, Nacho Cheese, Chili, Bacon available as an extra cost
Chicken
Popcorn Chicken$5.29
Popcorn Chicken & Wedges$5.99
Condiments
Ketchup, mayo, onions, lettuce, dill pickles, sweet relish & mustard. Tomato, Nacho Cheese, Chili, Bacon available as an extra cost
Pasta Salad
Rotini Pasta, Shredded Cheese and your choice of either Popcorn Chicken, Grilled Chicken or Chicken Salad$6.47

Some of Our Lafayette Frozen Custard Flavors

Our Frozen Custard Flavors
JumboXLargeLargeMediumSmallKiddy
Cake Cones & Dishes$5.75$5.00$4.25$3.50$2.50$1.50
Waffle Cones$6.50$5.75$5.00$4.25$3.25
Vanilla, Chocolate, Twist, Strawberry, Mint Chip, Blue Moon, Black Raspberry, and Pineapple Sherbet.

Munchies

Our Munchies
Potato Wedges & Cheese$3.99
Potato Wedges$3.09
Cheese Fries$3.29
French Fries$2.29
Corn Nuggets$3.99
Gouda Mac & Cheese Bites$3.99
Soft Pretzel$3.19
Bosco Sticks$3.99
Onion Rings$3.99
Coney Cheese Fries$3.99
Breaded Pickles$3.99
Nachos & Cheese$3.59
Breaded Mushrooms$3.99

Burgers

Lafayette's Finest Burgers
Bacon Cheeseburger
$7.49
Texas Burger
$7.49
Wisconsin Cheeseburger
$7.49
Spicy Jalapeño Burger
$7.49
Coney Cheeseburger$7.49
All of Lafayette’s Finest Burgers are made using r Meats’ ground round, and cooked fresh when you order. (8 minute cook time)

Drinks

Fountain DrinksJumboLargeRegularSmall
Old Fashion Soda
Vanilla Frozen Custard and flavored soda water: Chocolate, Strawberry, Vanilla, Lemon, Lime, Boysenberry, Pineapple, or Tiger's Blood
$3.99$3.29$2.49
Floats
Vanilla Frozen Custard with Coke, Root Beer, Sprite, or any of the Diet Cokes
$3.99$3.29$2.49
Shakes
Vanilla, Chocolate, Strawberry, Pineapple, Butterscotch, Marshmallow, Cherry, Boysenberry, Lime, Lemon, Tiger's Blood, Mint, Black Raspberry, Blue moon, or Hot Fudge
$5.44$3.80$2.28
Malts
Shake with malted milk, same flavors as shakes
$5.81$4.17$2.65
Chunky Shake
Vanilla shake with Snicker's, M&M's, Butterfinger's, Reece's Pieces, Reece's Cup, or OREO
$7.32$5.52$3.64
Slush
Cherry, Blue Raspberry, Strawberry, Grape, Orange, Lemon Lime, Watermelon and Pomegranate
$3.75$2.75$1.75
Brain Freeze
½ Shake ½ Slush, same flavors as slush
$5.86$4.04$2.52
Coke Cooler, Sprite Spritzer, Popo's Punch
½ slush
$2.83$2.12
Drinks
Coke - Diet Coke - Coke Zero - Barq's Root Beer - Sprite - Caffeine-Free Diet Coke
Peak Tea Unsweetened - Peak Sweet Tea
Flavored with: Vanilla, Cherry, Chocolate, Lemon, Boysenberry, Lime, Marshmallow, and Tiger's Blood --- extra $0.28 per shot
$2.57$1.87$1.49$1.17
Fruit Drink
Our secret blend of citrus juices
$5.23$3.27$2.52$1.78
Phosphates
Ice, soda water, and flavor: Vanilla, Cherry, Lime, Lemon, Boysenberry, and Tiger's Blood
$2.34$1.75$1.50
Triple filtered Lafayette’s Mighty Tasty Water
In foam cup with ice, lid and straw
32 oz
$1.31
20 oz
$1.17
Icy Cup
Ice pellets with flavoring; Vanilla, Cherry, Lemon, Boysenberry, Lime, and/or Tiger's Blood
$2.69$2.10$1.85
Bag of Frozen Custard Ice
Our delicious ice is filtered FOUR times for taste and purity!
$3.29
Enjoy your delicious treats on our beautiful open air patio!

Allergen Warning

We serve products made with and/or in close proximity to:

Dairy (milk); Nuts (Peanuts, Pecans, etc.); Egg; Soy; and Wheat. We cannot guarantee allergen-free.

Stop by our shop from March 1 to October 31 to make the Original Frozen Custard
part of your very own family tradition, just like ours.